Google Answers Why Entire Top 10 is “Stolen” Content

by | Jan 21, 2022 | SEO Search Engine Optimization, Uncategorized, Websites | 0 comments

An editor from the popular news site The Verge tweeted that a new article was replaced on page one of Google’s search results by other sites that had copied it. Danny Sullivan answers why that is happening.

Copied Content that Ranks Frustrates Publishers

Copied content that outranks the original is something that publishers have expressed frustration about for many years.

Some of the complaints are due to a misunderstanding.

For example, when a person searches a nonsense phrase like randomly selected words from an article, Google doesn’t know what to do with that’s not a real search query and there is no answer for a nonsense phrase.

So what Google does is to default to a text search, which means that Google is returning search results based on the words in a search query matching the words on a web page.

The real test for whether copied content is outranking the original content is when copied content outranks the original content for competitive keywords that users actually make.

Should a Page Rank Twice if It’s in a Top Stories Result?

But this situation that popped up introduces a different scenario. What happened is that Google will not rank an article headline in the top of the normal search results if that web page is already ranking in the Top Stories featured results, at the top of the web page.

Top Stories is a featured result where Google shows news articles related to a search query.

So if someone searches for a headline Google will usually show the article at the top of the search results in a Top Stories section.

But in this case it doesn’t show the original article in the top of the normal search results because of what Google calls deduplication, an algorithm that stops the same page from ranking twice.

So the question is, should Google rank the same page twice, once in the Top Stories and again at the top of the normal search results?

Entire First Page Consists of Stolen Content

Someone from The Verge tweeted that aside from Google’s featured news section at the top of the search results, a search for a headline from a new article resulted in Google showing an entire top ten that consists of nothing but stolen content.

The person tweeted:

“Hey Google, I just searched for a headline that was published on my website and the ENTIRE FIRST PAGE after the news box was of websites stealing our content. The Verge didn’t show up until page 2.

This problem is getting worse.”

Google’s Danny Sullivan acknowledged that writers searching with a headline expect to see their articles ranking at the top of the search results, not on page two.

But he also noted that searching by headline is not necessarily how regular searchers would search.

Danny’s response is debatable. A reasonable argument could be made that many people search the title of an article when they want to find it to share with a friend or on social media. So there is a real reason why people other than the author of an article may search for the title of an article.

Danny Sullivan from Google tweeted:

“We’ll take a look. I know searching by headline is common for writers and yes, I’d expect this to show first for that. But it doesn’t reflect how most people might seek this content (and for how they might search, I do find it). But again, we’ll look to improve.”

Danny next followed up with an explanation for why an original article ranks on page two for it’s own headline:

Search Queries That Trigger Alternative Search Results

Danny Sullivan’s next tweet explains how a search query with a lot of terms, like a headline term, causes Google’s algorithm to sort of drop out and begin return search results that are more like old style keyword searches, where the search results are not based on search intent or links but just based on the keywords themselves.

Here is what Danny tweeted:

As I mentioned above, there is a search intent behind searching for headlines. It may be that Google hasn’t recognized “headline-oriented searches” as a search intent that the algorithm should be aware of.

Danny continued his answer:

News Articles and Deduplication

Deduplication is when Google attempts stop one article from ranking twice in the search results. Danny Sullivan stated that the reason an article might not appear in the regular search results is if it is already ranking in the Top Stories and if that Top Stories ranks at the top of the page.

So the question is, is this a situation where a web page should rank twice, because a user might want to see the original article at the top of the search results, even if it’s already in the Top Stories section?

Once the Top Stories section disappears the news article should rank at the top of the search results.

Content is Top Ranked After Top Stories is Gone

Content Ranked at Top

And that, as can be seen in the above screenshot, is what is happening right now.

This is an interesting question where Google has to decide what is fair for the publisher and what is useful for the searcher.

Source link

Three Key Facebook Metrics to Understand Ad Performance

Three Key Facebook Metrics to Understand Ad Performance

My fellow digital marketers – before we talk about Facebook performance metrics, please complete this short survey. Question: Why do you create new Facebook ads?A. Out of pure habit.B. Our creative team never has enough work to do.C. Because ABT – “Always Be Testing”...

14 Strategies to Promote Your Business Through PPC

14 Strategies to Promote Your Business Through PPC

Are you getting low-quality traffic through your PPC campaigns?  Are fraud clicks draining your revenue from the PPC? Is your return on investment on PPC not as expected?  Even though PPC advertising is an integral part of an effective marketing strategy, poor tactics...

Use Customer Lifetime Value to Find More of Your Best Customers

With new privacy rules continually changing the landscape of third-party data, brands are increasingly becoming more focused on understanding their current customers in order to make more sophisticated marketing decisions. One approach to this is utilizing customer...

Tips for Optimizing a Localized PPC Account

Tips for Optimizing a Localized PPC Account

Before jumping into the components of a local PPC account and why it matters, we should first define what constitutes a local PPC account. The basic definition is that it targets customers within a specific region. The strategy for localized PPC specifically involves...

How Automation Hurts Rank, And How to Fix It

Imagine you are offered an opportunity to have control of all the creative, copy, and budget in your Google Ads account (or your paid media platform of choice) put in the hands of an anonymous six-year-old user. Each day, you are allowed to tell them whether they...

Content Marketing and PPC Advertising: Better Together

Content Marketing and PPC Advertising: Better Together

While some businesses invest solely in one type of advertising and marketing, like social media, others thrive by seamlessly combining multiple strategies, like content marketing and pay-per-click (PPC) advertising. Both of these methods can give a boost to your...

Pricing Plans

MediaQuad Membership Levels

Select one of the 8 plans below that best fits your needs.


Why wouldn't I just hire a full-time marketing team?

Great question! Hiring a full-time marketing team can be costly, with salaries and benefits easily exceeding $500,000 per year. Plus, you may not always have enough work to keep them busy, leading to wasted resources.

With MediaQuad’s subscription model, you can scale up or down as needed, ensuring you’re only paying for the services you need.


Is there a limit to how many requests I can have?

Once subscribed, you’re able to add as many marketing and web development requests to your queue as you’d like, and they will be delivered one by one unless you are on the Enterprise plan.

How fast will I receive my marketing deliverables?

On average, most requests are completed in just a few days. However, more complex requests can take longer.


Who are the marketers and developers?

MediaQuad is a team of experienced marketing and web development professionals. You’ll be working directly with our team, ensuring consistent, high-quality results.

How do I pause my subscription?

We understand you may not have enough marketing and web development work to fill up every month. That’s where pausing your subscription comes in handy. You can pause and resume your subscription as often as you need to ensure you’re only paying when you have work available for that month.

What software do you use?

We use a variety of industry-standard tools and software. If you use it, we probably have or currently use it too. Seriously, this is what we do everyday.

How do I request marketing and web development services?

MediaQuad offers a ton of flexibility in how you request services. You can request directly via our platform, share Google docs or wireframes, or even record a brief video. If it can be linked to or shared in our platform, it’s fair game.

What if I don't like the deliverable?

No problem! We’ll continue to revise the deliverable until you’re 100% satisfied.

What if I only have a single request?

That’s fine. You paid for a month’s worth of work, so don’t throw it away. Remember to submit a pause email or pause task in Trello. We’ll note how many business days you have left in your month, and you can come back when you need more marketing or web development services.

Are there any refunds if I don't like the service?

Due to the high-quality nature of our work, we do not issue refunds. However, we’re committed to ensuring your satisfaction and will work with you to address any concerns.

Need to talk first?

Schedule a call

Learn more about how MediaQuad works and how we can serve you.